SEONovember 17, 20268 min read

    Is SEO worth it for a small business? (And is AI killing it?)

    Is SEO worth it for a small business? When it pays off, when it may not, when to wait, how to check in Search Console, and what Google says about AI answers.

    By Click Katha
    Click Katha graphic with the headline "Is SEO worth it for a small business?" and the sub-line "And is AI killing it?", beside a level balance scale with empty pans.

    Is SEO worth it for a small business? Often, yes, but only when three things are true: people search on Google for what you sell, your site can be found when they do, and you (or someone you pay) can do the work. You don't need to take an agency's word for it, and that includes ours. Google's own advice and your Search Console data will tell you most of what you need. Below: a check you can run yourself, when to pay for help, when to wait, and what Google says about AI answers.

    What "worth it" really means for a small business

    Google is frank about the trade-off. Its guide Do you need an SEO? opens like this: "Deciding to hire a company or person to do search engine optimization (SEO) for your website in Google Search is a big decision that can potentially improve your site's visibility and save you time, but you can also risk damage to your site and reputation."


    So the real question isn't whether SEO works in general. It's whether it would work for you. Ask yourself three plain questions:


    • Do your customers look for your service on Google?

    • Can they find your site when they do?

    • Would more of those visits matter to your business?


    If you can't answer the first two yet, the next section shows you where to look. For the wider picture, here's what SEO for a small business actually involves.

    Check it yourself first: what Search Console already tells you

    Search Console is free, and it shows your own site's data rather than anyone's sales pitch. In Google's words, "The Performance report shows important metrics about how your site performs in Google Search results." (Search Console Help)


    Here's the check:


    1. Open Search Console and choose Performance.

    2. Leave the date range as it is. "The default view of the report shows click and impression data for your site in Google Search results for the past three months."

    3. Open the Queries tab. This is where you "Learn which queries are bringing traffic to your site".

    4. Look for searches that describe what you sell, and compare impressions with clicks.


    Two terms to know. Impressions: "How many times your site appeared in Search results." Clicks: "The number of times a user clicked your site from Google Search results." Impressions tell you whether Google shows you. Clicks tell you whether people choose you.


    Typing your own service into Google on your phone isn't a reliable test. Google says so itself: "Even if a query appears in your list, you might not see your site in results if you run the same query in Google Search."


    AI traffic isn't hidden somewhere else. Google says sites that appear in these features "are included in the overall search traffic in Search Console", and they show up in the same Performance report under the "Web" search type (AI features and your website). Google's AI guide also points to a separate view: "To measure how your content is performing in generative AI features on Google Search and Discover, use the Generative AI performance report".


    No Search Console yet? Here's how to track your searches in Google Search Console.

    What to look for

    • Whether your services show up at all, in any wording.

    • Pages showing up for the wrong things, such as a blog post appearing where your service page should.

    • No impressions at all for your main service.


    There's no magic number. What matters is whether these searches match the work you want.

    When SEO is usually worth paying for

    Google names the best moment itself: "For example, a great time to hire is when you're considering a site redesign (the earlier, the better), or planning to launch a new site." It then adds: "However, a good SEO can also help improve an existing site."


    Paying for help also tends to make sense when you don't have the hours for the technical side, or when technical issues keep your pages out of Google's index. Our page on when hiring help makes sense goes further.


    For cost, see how much SEO costs for a small business in the UK.

    When it may not be worth paying for yet

    Google's guide is honest about this too: "If you run a small local business, you can probably do much of the work yourself." Before you hand over any money, read what you can do yourself before paying anyone.


    Two other reasons to wait.


    No one is searching for what you sell. If Search Console shows no searches that describe your service, SEO can't create demand that isn't there.


    Your site is about to change. If a redesign or new site is coming, sort that first and bring SEO in early, as Google suggests. There's little point paying to improve pages you're about to replace.

    Is SEO dead now with AI?

    No. If you've heard SEO is dead because of AI, Google answers the point directly in its guide to generative AI features: "Is SEO still relevant for generative AI search? In short, yes! The best practices for SEO continue to be relevant because our generative AI features on Google Search are rooted in our core Search ranking and quality systems."


    Google's "Do you need an SEO?" page even lists "Optimizing for generative AI" among the useful services SEOs can offer. From Google's side, as the AI guide puts it, this is "still SEO".


    One AI-specific setting is worth checking. Google says: "In addition to the technical requirements for Search, a site must be included in Search generative AI features in Search Console to be eligible for display in generative AI features on Google Search." You don't have to switch anything on. The control sits under Settings > Search generative AI, and Include is "the default control for all properties" (Search Console Help). Just check that nobody has changed it.


    ChatGPT is a separate question: see how ChatGPT search finds websites.


    Be wary of anyone who promises you a spot in AI answers. Google's AI guide is plain: "Indexing and serving aren't guaranteed." That applies to us too.


    For the acronyms, start with what AEO (answer engine optimisation) means. For hands-on help, see our AI SEO services.

    How to judge an SEO offer before you pay

    Google's guide sets the bar. On audits: "An SEO audit should be about giving you realistic estimates of improvement, and an estimate of the work involved."


    On AI, it suggests asking: "If they have advice on optimizing for AI experiences (also known as "AEO" "GEO" services), is their advice aligned with Google Search's official guidance on optimizing for generative AI features?"


    If a tool or agency offers you a so-called AI visibility score, remember what Google's AI guide says: "No third-party tool has access to our internal ranking or AI systems". And treat any guarantee with suspicion, because "No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google." For the rest, see the red flags to watch for in an SEO quote.

    A quick way to decide: is SEO worth it for a small business like yours?

    Answer yes or no to each line:


    • People search for what I sell, and I've checked this in Search Console.

    • My site shows up for at least some of those searches, or could with some work.

    • I don't have the hours to do the basics myself.

    • I'm launching or redesigning a site soon.

    • More of those visits would matter to my business.


    Mostly yes? It's worth getting a quote. Mostly no? Start with the free basics and look at Search Console again later.

    FAQs

    Is SEO worth it for a local business?

    Often, yes, if local customers search for what you offer. Google says a small local business can probably do much of the work itself. Open the Queries tab in Search Console's Performance report. If searches for your service appear there, there's demand to work with, and SEO is worth a closer look.

    Is SEO dead now with AI?

    No. Asked whether SEO is still relevant for generative AI search, Google answers "In short, yes!" Its AI features, including AI Overviews and AI Mode, are rooted in its core Search ranking and quality systems, so the same best practices still apply.

    Will AI replace SEO?

    Google doesn't treat it that way. It says SEO best practices "continue to be relevant" because its AI features are rooted in its core Search ranking and quality systems, and it lists optimising for generative AI among the useful services SEOs provide. Treat confident forecasts with caution.

    Can a beginner do SEO?

    Yes, much of it. Google's own guidance says a small local business can probably do much of the work itself. Start with the Search Console check in this guide, and get help when the technical work or a site redesign needs more time or skill than you have.

    Is SEO worth it if I already pay for Google Ads?

    They're separate decisions. Google says: "Advertising with Google won't have any effect on your site's presence in our search results." Organic listings are also free, because "it costs nothing to appear in our organic search results".

    Next step

    If the checks above point to yes, see our SEO plans and prices, or ask us a question. If they point to no, that's a useful answer too.

    Share this article